Mastering a Song – What Does It Mean?

I just read this question: What does mastering a song mean? That’s a great question, actually.  Here’s the answer: nobody knows.  Nobody, that is, but a small and exclusive cabal whose members are sworn to keep the sacred arts a secret until their dying days. 

Well that’s what it feels like to me sometimes.  Interviews with members of the cabal, I mean professional audio mastering community, always seem to hint (or sometimes outright state) that mere mortals could never understand the complexities and subtleties involved in actual mastering. 

I say “actual” because it is also hinted that what we mortals call mastering is laughably over-simplified, like cave people banging flint together to make fire.

You know, now that I read the above paragraph out loud, I think it’s possible I underwent some sort of psychological trauma at the hands of a few non-representative individuals calling themselves mastering engineers several years ago. 

I’m led to understand that things are better now, and that they may never have been that bad even back then.  OK, now that the air is cleared let’s talk about mastering a song.

A bit of history

In the old days before mp3 or CDs or even cassettes and 8-tracks, consumers pretty much had to rely on records to hear recorded music.  Musicians would go to recording studios to record onto wide strips of magnetic tape that simply could not be played back on any consumer device (unless that consumer was someone like Les Paul…but that’s another story). 

So if the recording were ever to be heard by members of the public, the studio people had to have a way to make the audio go from those wide strips of tape onto a flat plastic (or rubber or shellac, depending on when we’re talking – see the wikipedia entry here) that normal people could play on their record players.

Actually, before there was magnetic tape, the recording engineers captured wound through recording “horns” which were hooked directly to a cutting stylus that would etch the disc directly.  But when magnetic tape allowed the creation of a master disc (from which mass produced records were made) to occur at a time and place completely separated from the time and place of the recording, specialization began to occur. 

The recording studios focused on capturing the sound. And separate facilities dedicated themselves to moving the audio on the non-consumer-playable tapes onto master discs,  which were then used to create lots and lots of plastic discs people could play at home, and eventually in their cars, etc.

Much specialized equipment was used to optimize the audio from tapes for use on the master discs, which needed to be as fault-free as possible, since millions of records were going to made from this disc. 

Mastering engineers became experts at optimizing already-recorded audio such that it would sound its best when it reached consumer ears.  That is why we still have mastering engineers today, and why mastering is still considered a separate process from recording and mixing.

Mastering engineers became experts at optimizing already-recorded audio such that it would sound its best when it reached consumer ears.

What kind of optimizing are we talking about here?

While recording and mixing is primarily concerned with capturing good tones and blending them properly, these processes are not always carried out in the most pristine of listening environments. 

And the ears of a mixing engineer are trained to make sure that the different sounds work and play well together.  So these folks use effects like EQ, reverb, and compression, etc. to accomplish this.  These engineers then send a mixed-down (see our article: What Does It Mean to Mix Down Audio?) version of the audio to a mastering house.

The mastering house has rooms that are designed to allow for totally unbiased listening, meaning that what the mastering engineer hears is as close as humanly possible to what is actually coming out of the speakers. 

Most regular home listening spaces (especially the converted  bedrooms of the intrepid home recordist) impart any number of changes to the sound so that what leaves the speakers (assuming they, themselves are reproducing what they get electronically) is not what reaches our ears. The source audio is being changed by the speakers, then the room. We never hear what the audio REALLY sounds like when listening in spaces like these.

So in addition to the finely tuned listening spaces, mastering facilities contain the best loud speakers and the best in equalization, compression and limiting tools.  Armed with these tools in these rooms, engineers whose ears are as sensitive as the noses of wine connoisseur or perfume testers perform audio surgery to produce music that sounds good on as many devices in as many places as possible. 

They can make certain sounds or instruments be more easily heard, or do the opposite and make overbearing or undesirable frequencies less prominent.  Remember, they aren’t working with a multi-track session, so they can’t just, say, turn the volume down on a bass guitar. 

The bass is already blended in with the kick drum, piano, voices, etc.  They have to turn up or down these specific frequencies on the final mix using targeted EQ and multiple-band compression and other mastering tools.

At the end of the day

Sometimes, when the mix engineer is good, the mastering is minor surgery.  But all to often they are sent audio that requires many hours of major surgery, or even miracles sometimes, to optimize audio for consumers.  Such is the life of a mastering engineer.

In the end, a fully mastered version of the audio is, as it was in the old days, ready to be mass-produced and distributed.

So can I master my own songs?

In an ideal world, I would recommend sending your mixed songs to a separate mastering provider. But this isn’t always feasible. And it can be expensive. But that doesn’t mean you have to learn to master your own songs.

There are now online mastering services that can instantly master songs that you upload. I tried one of these and to my ears, it sounded as good as one of my songs that was sent to a “mastering engineer.”

Some of the online mastering services are:

• LANDR
• eMastered and
• CloudBounce

I don’t think it could hurt to try these. Purists would probably scoff at the idea that these could ever stand up to something worked on by a seasoned mastering engineer. But it is almost certainly better than doing it yourself if you don’t know much about mastering at home.